Trust is expensive. Skepticism isn't.

Start free. Pay when doubting becomes a habit.

Free

$0

Five chances to save yourself some money.

  • Five free analyses
  • The full BS Rating
  • Our honest opinion
  • eBay listings
Start skeptical
Most skeptical

Skeptik Pro

$9/month

For the people friends send listings to.

  • Unlimited second opinions
  • Private analysis history
  • Saved Skeptik reports
  • Community confidence
  • Priority analysis

Why Skeptik exists

We don't think everyone's lying. We just think the internet gives strangers a little too much credit.

Every day, people spend hundreds or thousands of dollars based on a few photos, a description, and a feedback score. Sometimes that's enough. Sometimes it isn't.

That's where Skeptik comes in. We don't try to prove a listing is legitimate. That's almost impossible. Instead, we ask a simpler question:

Would an experienced buyer spend their own money here?

That single question drives everything Skeptik does. Seller history. Photos. Buyer feedback. Pricing. Marketplace patterns. Every signal exists for one reason: to understand whether we'd feel comfortable buying it ourselves.

Experience matters. An experienced buyer doesn't just notice red flags. They notice combinations. A stock photo from a large retailer is probably normal. The same stock photo from a brand-new seller asking thousands of dollars makes us pause. Context matters. Always has.

Skeptik isn't replacing your judgment. It's sharing ours. The goal isn't to tell you what to buy. It's to help you notice what experienced buyers notice before spending your money.

Skeptik was inspired by two decades of buying, selling, and occasionally getting burned. We figured it was time those lessons became useful to someone besides us.

What Skeptik looks at

Seller History

How long they have sold, how much, and whether their track record holds up.

Photos

Whether the images prove the seller actually has the item in hand.

Buyer Feedback

What recent buyers actually experienced, including trust-breaking problems.

Price

How the asking price compares to what similar items really sell for.

Description

Whether the listing reads like a real owner wrote it, or like a script.

AI Image Detection

Signs that photos were edited, generated, or lifted from another listing.

What's next

Today

eBay

Coming soon

  • Facebook Marketplace
  • Mercari
  • OfferUp
  • Poshmark
  • GOAT
  • StockX

Questions

Does Skeptik guarantee a listing is safe?

No. Skeptik gives risk analysis from observable signals. It does not guarantee a listing is safe, authentic, or fairly priced. The final call is always yours.

Which marketplaces work today?

eBay today, with more on the way.

What do I get for free?

Five free analyses. You can start without an account.

What does Pro add?

Unlimited analyses plus the deeper reads: current pricing context, recent buyer feedback, and the full image intelligence check.

Do you store my payment details?

No. Payments run through Stripe, so we never see or store your card.